The US Senate on Thursday rejected, by 48 votes to 51, a war powers resolution directing President Donald Trump to withdraw American forces from hostilities with Iran. The vote halted a measure that had cleared the House of Representatives in September.

The text under consideration was the concurrent resolution H.Con.Res. 93. According to Middle East Monitor, three Republican senators, Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski and Rand Paul, broke with most of their party to vote in favour. Senator John Fetterman was the only Democrat to vote against it, while Democratic Senator Chris Murphy did not vote.

The resolution was sponsored by Democratic Representative Seth Moulton and passed the House in September by 220 votes to 204. The failure to repeat that margin in the Senate showed that opponents of the war have been unable to assemble a majority in the upper chamber.

The breakdown also showed that neither party voted as a single bloc. Three Republicans voting yes and one Democrat voting no suggest that divisions over the Iran war sometimes cut across party lines. No White House comment on the vote was reported.

Background

Throughout the war launched by the United States and Israel in February, members of Congress have pressed the administration for more information on its cost, strategy and casualties. The US Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war and approve spending, while the 1973 War Powers Resolution requires a president to notify Congress within 48 hours of military action taken without its approval and to end it within 60 days unless authorised.

Murphy, who did not take part in the vote, said in early October that the Pentagon had blocked his access to Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar and accused the administration of hiding the war’s effects from Congress. The Pentagon said in August that more than 750 American troops had been wounded.

Why it matters

Had the resolution passed the Senate, it would have been a concrete step by Congress to assert its war powers. Its defeat means the executive has weathered the most direct congressional attempt yet to constrain the military campaign against Iran.

Even so, a margin as narrow as 48-51 shows that the war remains contested in Washington. Support from Republican ranks indicates that criticism of the administration’s war policy is not confined to the opposition. Whether Congress now applies pressure through information requests, spending or a new resolution will be watched closely.

Source: Middle East Monitor · Image: Martin Falbisoner, CC BY-SA 3.0